Monday, June 8, 2020

A visit to a local used CD store

A couple of months back I drove across the USA by myself, specifically from New York to Nashville to see a live wrestling event. I saw Ring of Honor: Bound by Honor at the Municipal Auditorium in Nashville, and was satisfied with how the event panned out. I sat in the second row.


A week later I found myself in Baton Rouge, Louisiana looking for something to do. One of my favorite hobbies is to peruse book stores and CD stores. I don't really listen to vinyl. I own about 10-12 vinyl records, and at a time I did listen to them, but I prefer CDs. There are some vinyl records I've recently become interested in, but I don't have a record player right now so those'll have to wait.


Anyway, in two visits, this is what I bought:

The Ramones - Loco Live
Bauhaus - 1979-1983 Volume One
BeeGees - Number Ones
The Breeders - Last Splash
Mountain - On Top
Morrissey - World of Morrissey

Other stuff: I almost bought Daft Punk - Random Access Memories, but skipped out on it, and when I returned it was gone. I noticed one album that caught my eye which was one of Jack Endino's band's albums, I think they're called, "Skin Yard." I bought a copy of the Armor for Sleep CD "Smile for Them" during this time also. I asked the owner if he had any Sly Stone CD's, he had some compilations (inside of a locked glass case) but I was looking for a particular one he didn't have. I also asked about Deep Purple's "Machinehead" which wasn't there.

The store was called, "The Exchange" and I recommend visiting, they have a lot of stuff you don't normally see, including B-sides, CD singles, rare albums and more. The owner was also friendly and interested in helping you find whatever it is you might be looking for.



Sunday, June 7, 2020

Ace Ventura: Pet Detective (Movie Review)

I just watched this classic for the first time since the movie's release, in 1994. I may have caught bits and pieces of the film on TV re-runs, but haven't seen the full movie from start to finish since at least 1996, or so.


Watching it back at age 32 gave me an opportunity to understand the movie more thoroughly. Before I dive into all of my opinions, a quick note. "Ace Ventura: Pet Detective," at just under 90 minutes, is the perfect length.

The plot of the movie back then was confusing for me, because I was 8 years old in 1996. I didn't understand the twists and turns of the story-line, and didn't understand all of the jokes.

What's actually hilarious is that when I was a little kid, in the climax of the movie, when Finkle is revealed to be Einhorn... I thought that Lois Einhorn had crapped her pants and there was a big load in her underwear, which is why it was funny.

As an adult, I realize it's actually because Finkle had just tucked his junk in between his legs and the "load" is actually his man parts. Heck, maybe I'll re-watch this film in my 60's and realize I was wrong back in my 30's as to why this scene is humorous. It's all up for debate.

My other takeaways from the film involve some of the less than kid-friendly humor that's thrown in, and how it's sort of like a rapid-fire collage of scenes. "Ace Ventura: Pet Detective" doesn't drag whatsoever. The relationship scenes between Courtney Cox and Jim Carrey are pretty enjoyable. I'd even venture to say the scene where they argue while in poolside lounge chairs is borderline endearing and dare I say, realistic.

Another scene that stuck out for me is when Ace breaks into a Los Angeles apartment complex. There are some shots interspersed that present a cool juxtaposition between a realistic look at life for some (either hard-working, or lazy) American one who likes to relax at his home and watch TV, and the cartoonish and very Hollywood character that is Ace Ventura, who scampers down the apartment complex walkways to eventually interact with this person.

I think the reason why this movie became so popular and such a phenomenon is because of the easy-to-understand, facial-expression-based humor from Ace. The over-the-top slapstick humor appeals to small children who relate to the type of interactions you see on Bugs Bunny, where every gesture is hyper-exaggerated.

The film also appeals to adults, with a somewhat complex detective/mystery subplot, and the macabre look into a disgraced football player who goes mental, and then changes his identity to become a woman in order to plot revenge on... a mega-famous archetype of Americana and pop culture, but also someone who is flawed himself in never having won "The Big Game," ... Mr. Dan Marino.

The writers certainly tossed every idea into the script except for the kitchen sink, and Jim Carrey pulls it all together with his performance.

"Ace Ventura: Pet Detective" combines gags, a light-hearted and easy-to-follow detective story-line and more complex and sort of "scary" elements. It accomplishes a lot in a short amount of time.

Tuesday, May 26, 2020

My NFL Score prediction app: Year 2 on the Google Play Store

I just updated my NFL Score Prediction game app. We are now entering Year #2 on the Google Play Store. You can download the application here (Android users, Google Play Store).
 
If you want to use the app, but do not have an Android phone, visit the direct URL: NFLScoreApp.com

The annual maintenance took me about 3-4 hours of work. This involved inputting the 2020 NFL schedule and resetting various internal knobs and levers. Not bad from a time standpoint... Although I will admit, I'm pretty lazy and I thought about just throwing my hands up and not renewing my server space about an hour in.

https://play.google.com/store/apps/details?id=xyz.appmaker.nbwebh&hl=en_US

It was pretty nice out today, so I missed out on the great weather but instead was stuck inside staring at the computer screen, which is one reason I left the tech industry to begin with, but whatever.

The application costs $20 a year for the server space and it cost me a one-time fee of $25 to become a Google Developer, so from a money standpoint, it's not a huge waste of money. It amounts to a couple of magazine subscriptions, more or less.

https://play.google.com/store/apps/details?id=xyz.appmaker.nbwebh&hl=en_US

This year (as opposed to 2019) I opened up the free app download to every single country that's available in the Google Play store. Last year I only had the application available to the U.S.A. and the United Kingdom.

Some improvements I made for the 2020 NFL Schedule: There is now a "My Stats" page that shows some bar graphs about your level of participation and gives your definitive ranking.

I redesigned the navigation to simplify it.

I limited the Leaderboard to the Top 25 users only.

I'm not sure how long I will continue to keep this app active, but I'm satisfied with how it's working as of now. I still believe in my concept, but I'd need major help to bring it to the next level.

If you are interested in working on or buying this application, i.e. purchasing the source code outright, shoot me an email. My address is listed on my "About Me" page on blogger. - Mike

Tuesday, May 5, 2020

Hooking up a mixer to a compressor or external preamp

I've been recording music for the past 3 years with a bizarre device, something I picked up online called the Peavey 10AT mixer. It's an audio mixer that has "AutoTune" built-in.

The Peavey 10AT mixer

Going back to the early days of my audio engineering interest, back in 2001 when I picked up my first recording device, a Fostex-MR8 digital multi-tracker, I didn't know what I was doing. I jumped into the home recording hobby at a time when digital recording was very new. Analog was inaccessible, because I knew nothing about tape machines, or even DAT, so I was forced to figure out digital recording. Without any real mentor figure, I had to teach myself everything. It was almost 100% trial and error.

I can remember often hearing advice, going back to the early days of my interest in sound recording, which was always, "You need a mixer." But, I didn't understand. How could I hook up an analog mixer to record the sound into a digital file on my computer? It didn't make sense.

Remember, this was 2001, and so the concept of an affordable audio interface (or even a well known one) wasn't yet possible. Hence why I was directed towards the Fostex MR-8 machine, a consumer grade, "Digital multi-tracker" that essentially recorded audio files onto an SD card that was inserted into the device.

The Fostex MR-8 Digital multi-tracker

The Fostex MR-8 forced you to "Bounce" your mixes into a final version before you were able to transfer them via USB to your desktop computer. This mix-down process was shaky, and I remember the set of steps required was possible, but not automatic. You had to make sure the file sizes and the lengths of the audio were proper, otherwise you'd be unable to mix-down and you'd be left with files stuck on the physical machine, unable to proceed with the USB transferring. It was less-than-ideal, to say the least. Regardless, I was able to do this even back then, when I was only 13 years old.

I guess, for the sake of thoroughness, I can talk about three other devices I've personally spent time using to record, in between the Fostex MR-8 device (in 2001) and the Peavey 10AT (2017-Present).

The Presonus Firepod

In 2006 I bought and used a Presonus Firepod. This was a unit that allowed for 8 microphones to be connected simultaneously, and each of the audio tracks to be recorded individually into a DAW (Digital Audio Workstation). So, this bridged many gaps for me at the time. First off, having eight microphone inputs was desirable. As a neophyte drum recordist, I saw plenty of videos about how and why you needed separate microphones for every drum on the drum kit (Although now I favor just using a stereo pair). I used the Firepod actively until about the fall of 2013, so it lasted me 7 years. The device suffers from preamps that contain some sort of digital "sheen" artifact that's unpleasant, although I will mention, if you record in a good environment and with the leveling properly set, you'll notice this "sheen" disappears entirely. Still, the Firepod didn't offer the most sterile input signal processing. Which is why....


The Focusrite Saffire Pro 14

In 2014, I bought a Focusrite Saffire Pro 14. This device solved the issues of the Firepod, because the input signal it offers is very dry and sterile, almost completely transparent. I can't say much about this device, as I ultimately found it sort of lifeless and less-than-inspiring. I guess the most interesting part of my ownership of the device was the fact I had to risk my life to pick it up. I walked on foot to a very remote FedEx pickup location, and found myself in a bad part of town. At one point I was surrounded by a gang, who were riding ATVs around the streets, and this was in the inner-city, in a very remote part of New York City. I felt like I was in an episode of the Sopranos, when they take a guy to the remote part of Coney Island, for instance, and all of the sudden he realizes what's about to happen.

The Focusrite ISA One Preamp

I did, however, attempt to liven up the Focusrite, with another piece of Focusrite gear, an ISA One analog Preamp. This was the first (and only) ever dedicated pre-amplifier I've owned and used. It's one piece of gear I somewhat regret letting go of, because it was pretty cool. I will mention, though, that it's only a one-channel device, so it's somewhat flawed in that sense. In order to hook up this preamp to the Focusrite Saffire Pro 14, I didn't have to try too hard, because I asked for help at the local Guitar Center (near Union Square in Manhattan) on what cables I'd need. The salesperson seemed to be knowledgeable, and let me know the exact cables I'd need. The ISA One included very easy-to-understand instructions as well, which helped me hook it up to the Saffire Pro 14 audio interface seamlessly. The ISA One performed well in that it livened up the input signal for the Focusrite Saffire Pro 14's AD conversion, and it also provided  more clarity to the signal, which I mostly utilized on the vocal tracks on the music I was recording at the time. It was pretty good, but I wasn't that into it.

From Wikipedia: In electronics, an analog-to-digital converter (ADC, A/D, or A-to-D) is a system that converts an analog signal, such as a sound picked up by a microphone or light entering a digital camera, into a digital signal.

The Teac A-3340S (Pictured without reels)

The other major device I used was a TEAC A-3340S. This was my first (and only) foray into fully analog recording. This device was interesting. I bought it off Craigslist and spent hours cleaning the heads with rubbing alcohol and cotton swabs, before running some brand new (at $65 a reel) tape through the machine. I was surprised to find out it actually worked, and seemed to be calibrated too. I used an analog mixer with this tape machine, namely a Yamaha MG series mixer.

Yamaha MG Series analog mixer

So at one point, I was able to record to 1/4" tape with the TEAC A-3340S, and then playback the tape through the Saffire Pro 14's AD converter and into my computers DAW, for a fully analog to digital experience. This was back in 2015, more or less.

Eventually, I lost my job and looked around at the extensive amount of equipment I had acquired and decided I ought to part ways with most of it, and ultimately I sold all of my gear except for an acoustic guitar and a pair of cheap Shure PGA57 dynamic microphones, for the sake of minimalism and simplicity. That was years ago.

The Peavey 10AT mixer

Obviously since then, I've been able to re-assess my recording interest and eventually found another job that paid well, and I was able to buy new and different recording equipment, and that's where I decided on the Peavey 10AT. And that's where everything came full circle.

The Peavey 10AT is not only a traditional analog mixer, it also allows you to stream the audio directly to your computer via USB (without any convoluted mix-down steps) with a built in AD converter. However, the 10AT has it's limitations, namely an inability to separate input signal feeds into separate tracks post AD conversion. Anyway, I was recently interested in adding some outboard gear to the Peavey 10AT and that's where I started to investigate how to hook up an external preamp or compressor to this mixer.

A block diagram of the signal flow for the Peavey 10AT

I've noticed the Peavey 10AT gives me a tonality that I've been able to work with, for sure, but how about the idea of using this Peavey 10AT as a traditional AD converter, much in the way I used my old Saffire Pro 14? How would I connect outboard gear to the mixer at the correct part of the signal path? That's where I checked out the above block diagram and considered the below schematic.

Schematic on how to connect a Warm WA12 MKII 500 preamplifier to an audio interface.
 
So if we inspect the schematic provided by Warm Audio, to show how to connect their WA12 MKII 500 preamplifier to an audio interface, we see it says, "Just plug it right into the front of your interface, into the first channel."

Well, upon closer inspection, it also says, "Buy our leveling amplifier and patch that between our preamp and your interface," but I'll disregard the inclusion of the leveling amp for now to avoid an in-depth discussion. But anyway, a leveling amplifier is a device that reduces the dynamic range of a signal, so the quieter parts become louder and the loudest parts become quieter. This effect creates a fuller or "richer" tonality to the signal, something I probably could've used with the Saffire Pro 14. But continuing on with the wiring discussion...

Inspecting the block diagram of the Peavey 10AT, you'll notice if I were to follow the above schematic and wired the Warm Audio output into the first channel input of my 10AT, I'd be running my microphone signal through TWO preamplifiers... the Warm Audio WA12 MKII 500 preamp AND the Peavey 10AT's built-in preamplifier , which obviously will muddy up the signal with excess gain. So, how to address this?

Looking at the Peavey 10AT block diagram, using channels 5 and 6 will allow us to bypass the Peavey 10AT's built-in preamplifier. This ought to work, however, we'll need to use the correct cables, and I believe these are referred to as "Stereo 1/4 inch" cables, or, rather, TRS cables, and also "Balanced 1/4 inch" cables. So you'll need this type of cable...

1/4" TRS male to XLR female cable

Just to double check, I read the Peavey 10AT official user's manual and found this:

"MIC/LINE INPUT (CH.1-8)
This combination input jack accepts a ¼” or XLR balanced plug. The XLR balanced input is optimized for a microphone or other low impedance source. The ¼” input is a TRS balanced type, and also accepts ordinary TS guitar cables."

Beyond 5/6's inputs, there are more channels on the Peavey 10AT mixer to consider: channels 9 and 10, and the AUX channel.

It seems like (again referencing the Peavey 10AT Block Diagram), channels 9/10 allow you to bypass the built-in EQ, but also disallow adding any built-in Digital FX to the signal, or applying AUX sends. So, it seems like using channels 9/10 isn't really designed exclusively for connecting outboard gear, but rather, running an external audio source into the mixer, like streaming audio from a radio, or an iPod, or something like that. Though, technically it can replicate the functionality of using channels 5 and 6, while also allowing you to explicity bypass the 10AT's built-in EQ. Channels 9/10 are basically just like Channels 5/6 minus a robust channel strip with Gain, L/R Panning, and Input Volume adjustment. With Channel 9/10 you're limited to a single master volume fader.

I guess, with the AUX channel, you are sending variable levels of each channel with an AUX dial to the AUX send outputs, which is useful for live mixing when your drummer asks for "More guitar" in his monitor. His monitor would be wired to the AUX send outputs, and the guitar's input, for instance, wired DI into Channel 4. By turning up the AUX dial on Channel 4, the drummer would hear his requested, "More guitar," in his monitor.

Of course, you can replace the drummer's monitor in the above example with, say, a piece of outboard gear, perhaps a rack-mounted EQ unit. Considering this idea, you are sending the guitar signal into the input of this rack-mounted EQ, instead of to a monitor.

By then connecting the output of that rack-mounted EQ back into a different input on the mixer, you are using the AUX function as an Effects Send/Return, or an Effects Loop. By turning the AUX dial on the guitar (Channel 4) up, you will send more of the guitar into the rack-mounted EQ, and subsequently back out of the rack-mounted EQ and into that separate channel on the mixer for playback.

So, bearing all this in mind, it seems Channels 5/6 are probably the way to go. So we've figured out how to hook up an external preamp to the Peavey 10AT, now what about a compressor as well? If we look at the back of this device below, FMR Audio's RNC 1773 compressor, we are given some clues on how this might work.

FMR Audio's Really Nice Compressor 1773 model, with unbalanced inputs/outputs

So this device has simple unbalanced 1/4" inputs and outputs. Now what?

If we follow the logic we found in the Peavey 10AT's block diagram, we notice on Channels 1/2, the 10AT's built-in preamplifier is first in the signal chain, and comes before the Peavey 10AT's built-in compressor. So, following that logic, with our outboard gear, we'd want to put the FMR RNC 1773 compressor AFTER the Warm Audio WA12 MKII 500 preamplifier in the signal chain.

Male to Male TRS (balanced) cable

Remember, we decided to connect the Warm Audio WA12 MKII 500 to channels 5/6 of the Peavey 10AT. So, the FMR Audio RNC 1773 will sit between the Warm Audio Preamp, and channels 5/6 of the Peavey 10AT. And... it seems as though, because the Warm Audio device offers us balanced XLR outputs, we're basically just patching the FMR compressor in with an additional male to male TRS cable. Pretty easy huh?

But wait, we're connecting cables between the balanced output of the Warm Audio preamp, and the unbalanced inputs/outputs of the FMR compressor to our balanced Peavey 10AT inputs. Now what? According to an article I found online, Mike Rivers, an audiologist tries to squash some rumors about balanced versus unbalanced connections, he tackles the issue head on:
  • "If you connect a balanced output to an unbalanced input you'll lose half the level. Sometimes, sometimes not. It depends on the output topology."
Much to my surprise, there are full-blown threads online with debates on what cables to use to connect this FMR Audio RNC Compressor much in the same way I'm suggesting here. One person even alleges that the creator of the FMR Audio compressor has told him in confidence the I/O for the 1773 is in fact balanced, despite the official documentation saying otherwise.

The "Quick start" guide for the RNC delivers official information:

"The RNC can be hooked into Tip-Ring-Sleeve (TRS) insert points found on many consoles where: TIP = Console insert out, RING = Console insert in, SLEEVE = Ground reference. This means that each channel of the RNC can be hooked to a each channel of a TRS console insert with a single TRS cable."
 
Needless to say, I'd probably go with strictly (balanced) TRS connections between the Warm Audio preamp, the RNC compressor and the Peavey 10AT mixer. Boom!!
 
Lastly, the Warm Audio preamp discussed is only one-channel, whereas the FMR compressor offers two-channels. So, ideally you'd want a 2-channel preamp, or you could just buy two (2) of the Warm audio preamps, so you can record in stereo and apply uniform compression to your stereo signal. Shazam!!

That concludes this discussion and history of my own recording experiences and tutorial/explanation on how to potentially patch in outboard gear with your digital mixer or AD converter. Until next time. - Mike.

Saturday, April 18, 2020

Top 5 Fast food restaurants

#5 McDonalds is hit or miss, but they remain in the top 5 due to menu items like the Big Mac, buttermilk chicken tenders, and two cheeseburger meal. Not to mention, their sundaes aren't bad, and neither is their hot or iced coffee. When there's a McDonalds available, I'm lovin it.


#4 The Wendy's menu benefits from hefty burger options, like the Baconator, and smaller dollar menu alternatives, like the Junior Bacon Cheeseburger. The burger buns are typically good, and you might be surprised by the freshness of the lettuce and tomato they provide. When your day isn't going so hot, you can stop the madness with an ice cold Frosty.


#3 Nathans offers classic Coney island taste and memorable hot dog crispness and flavors. There's a reason why the ultimate hot dog eating championship is held at a Nathans. Their fries are notable but it's really about the idea of crushing down a two hot dog meal like a boss, then proceeding to rock the socks off of everyone you encounter afterwards.


#2 Burger King is a fast food haven for the enlightened. Their signature Whopper sandwich gives you a larger burger than McDonalds could ever dream about offering, and their chicken tenders with Tangy barbeque sauce, if dished out properly, will give you that awesome feeling like you can't get anywhere else. Lasting memories are created at B.K. for a reason and that's why they rank so highly on this Top 5 list.


#1 Ranch 1 is simply unrivaled. You don't have to feel like a sloppy mess when you decide to eat there, because they offer what seem like legitimately healthy options. Their grilled chicken sandwiches are prepared to excellent taste. It's the type of place you could order several trays from at the mall's food court and sit there basking in glory of how epic your life has become. When someone asks you where you've been all day and you mention the words Ranch 1, watch for their subtle nod of approval, as if to confirm, you sir are a champion.

Sunday, April 5, 2020

Kurt Cobain's music ethics and copyright complexities

Recently I was in conversation with someone about music royalties. I mentioned I wrote some music I'm excited about, because I believe it will earn me money, and strangely, this was a motivating factor in recording the music, though this has never typically been the case for me. Even better, because I am the sole author of the music, I'll retain full rights and earn 100% of the royalties, but what about when you're in a band?

In an effort to discuss legalities and close any gaps between the truth and reality, I'll use Nirvana as an example to explore the finer points of  music royalty distribution. As anyone who knows me understands this is one of my favorite topics. Bear in mind, I'm not an expert, just a fan.


Years ago, I bid on a tape machine on eBay, specifically an Otari MX-5050 Mark III 8 track recorder. Of course, that specific machine was the exact unit that was used to record Nirvana's debut album, "Bleach." That album was recorded by Jack Endino, who billed the band roughly $600 for the recordings. After Bleach came "Nevermind" and Nirvana hit the big-time. With their meteoric rise into super-stardom, Nirvana's music royalty situation became more complex.


So, I was pretty sure that there was some sort of major royalty-redistribution that went on during Nirvana's major label career, but I wasn't positive. I did some research and found out the facts. First off, I searched the public records using the online copyright database and searched for copyrights filed for "Cobain, Kurt." I found them all and inspected "Smells Like Teen Spirit" first. It looks like this:


So we're seeing 
"Appears on Nevermind," 
"Published by Sub Pop," 
"Date of Creation: 1991," 
"Date of Publication: August 15 1991"
"Copyright Claimant: Virgin Songs, Inc. & The End of Music"
"Authorship on Application: words and music: Virgin Songs, Inc, employer for hire of Kurt, Krist and Dave."


So it seems like through an agreement with Virgin Songs, Inc. and "End of Music", the label that released "Bleach," known as Sub Pop, retained publishing rights over "Smells like teen spirit," and likely all of the tracks on Nevermind, which is something I'm familiar with, and an out-of-the-gate complexity. But I was more interested in the Kurt Cobain royalty redistribution that happened retroactively. As I looked through the online database, a record titled "Transfer of Copyright," caught my eye. It looks like this:


And here we're seeing that on September 7th of 1993, Fourteen (14) Nirvana song copyrights were transferred from 1. Krist, Dave and Kurt TO 2. Kurt Cobain doing business as "End of Music." And we're also seeing: "Date of execution" as May 6th 1991. So this was retroactively executed four months prior to the commercial release of Nevermind.

When we click into the "List of Titles" link we see this:


So, for example, we're seeing this:
"Smells like teen spirit / By Virgin Songs, Inc., as employer for hire of Kurt Cobain, Krist Novoselic & David Grohl. PA 541-273."

But mostly we're seeing this:
"In bloom / By Virgin Songs, Inc., as employer for hire of Kurt Cobain. PA 541-279."

This is all well and good, but what about the actual Nevermind album's liner notes? I have a copy of an original 1991 version on CD. I popped it open and took a photo of the credits:


Notice it says, "All songs lyrics by Kurt Cobain / Music by Nirvana." and "All rights controlled and administered by Virgin Songs, Inc."

Now what does this all mean? Let's break it down...

We'd have to get a copy of Nirvana's recording contract with Virgin Songs, Inc. and their agreement with "End of Music" to really know what their deal looked like in terms of the rights, but from what we can see here, it seems like Kurt Cobain and Nirvana retained their intellectual property rights despite the fact they may have transferred the control/distribution rights for Nevermind (at least for a duration of time) over to Virgin Songs, Inc. most likely via the agreement/partnership with "End of Music."

Where does the DGC (David Geffen Company) record label imprint come into play? From what I can tell, DGC was responsible for the physical distribution of Nevermind (And would I guess financed the manufacturing of the discs via an agreement with a disc-making plant, perhaps a Sony plant), whereas the publishing rights were split between Virgin Songs, Inc., "End of Music" and Sub Pop. Of course, this blog post mainly focuses on the rights-to-royalties, which all happens after sales. An interesting note is that upon release, Nevermind was certified Gold (500,000 copies) and Platinum (1,000,000 copies) in November of 1991, only two months after it was released. The average cost of a CD in 1991 was $12.91 according to the "US Industrial Outlook 1993" book.


When it comes to royalties, it appears as though, through the original deal with Virgin Songs, Inc. Nirvana as Kurt, Dave and Krist were splitting royalties off Nevermind three ways, so each member was earning 33.3% of royalties, and this was being paid out (via control) by Virgin Songs, Inc. who, we see listed in the "Authorship" section of the "Teen spirit" copyright, as an "employer for hire" of Kurt, Krist and Dave. 

So, why did Kurt Cobain file for Copyright transfer if he already had an agreement with Virgin Songs, Inc. through his "End of Music" company? It's been written that all of the sudden, Cobain decided he should earn a higher royalty, and this filing represents concrete action taken to change the royalty distributions for Nevermind. But why not just negotiate with Virgin Songs, Inc. to pay out Dave and Krist less money through the agreement with Cobain's company, "End of Music?" It's possible that Kurt went to David Geffen and asked for a higher percentage of royalties. The "Transfer of Copyright" filing allowed Cobain to bypass any subsequent negotiations entirely. The filing provided Cobain with rights to 100% of the royalties for each of the tracks with only his name listed.

So, to summarize, Nevermind was released in the fall of 1991. Then, all of the sudden in 1993, Kurt Cobain decides to exercise his intellectual property rights over several Nirvana songs retroactively (i.e. music recordings), and reclaims ownership of 14 of the titles. How does he do this? Is it ethical?

If we again inspect the liner notes for Nevermind we're seeing, "All songs lyrics by Kurt Cobain," and, "All music by Nirvana," in addition to the "All rights controlled and administered by Virgin Songs, Inc." I guess the wording here is key, because Virgin Songs Inc. may "control and administer" the rights, but that doesn't mean they exclusively own the rights. 

As we see on the copyright for "Teen spirit," the claimant is both "Virgin Songs, Inc." and "End of Music." This "End of Music" company likely garnered Kurt Cobain the leverage to exercise his rights over his own intellectual property, which is exactly what he did in 1993.

The fact the liner notes spell out, "Music by Nirvana," and "Lyrics by Kurt Cobain" is evidence of Kurt's intellectual property rights over the lyrics, and for the music, we must venture beyond closed doors (and inspect the music ethics of Kurt Cobain) to inspect whether or not he was the sole creator/writer of the music

"All music written and recorded by Nirvana," would have been a distinct difference from "All music by Nirvana," in that the word "written" is left out of the latter. In Cobain's "Transfer of Copyright" filing, we're seeing he legally reclaims his intellectual property rights as the sole writer of several Nirvana tracks (i.e. music, composition, sound recordings). So, with the "Transfer of Copyright," Kurt is saying, "Yeah, the music is by Nirvana, but I wrote it."


Bear in mind, Nirvana was the biggest band in the world shortly after the release of Nevermind, and this was a time before digital music. In order to listen to the CD you had to buy it, it was that simple, and people loved to buy CDs to play on their home stereo and in their cars. 

My point being, Kurt Cobain had a ton of power if he went to Virgin Songs, Inc. or DGC and said, "Hey I want to do this," they wouldn't want to poke the bear. He was earning them millions of dollars with his intellectual property that they controlled the rights to. If they weren't careful, Cobain could potentially relinquish them of their control over the rights legally (perhaps before or after his recording contract expired). What he seemed to do in 1993 was to explicitly restructure the rights-to-royalties for these 14 songs, through Virgin Songs, Inc., who retained control over the rights, and he did this via a transfer of copyright back to himself. How?

So, what seems to have happened is Kurt Cobain went to either his label, DGC or "Virgin Songs, Inc." and said something like, "I want a higher share of the royalties because I am the primary songwriter, and in fact, I've written all of this material myself. It even says so in the liner notes for Nevermind." 

What Virgin Songs, Inc. or DGC said in reply was likely, "Ok, what we need to do is remove Krist and Dave from the copyrights, and then we'll transfer that portion of the royalties back to you." And this is how the royalties were re-structured, in a way that likely mirrored the reality of the creation process, you'd hope, from an ethical standpoint and not as a result of Cobain's own power trip. 

In an interview with Melody Maker magazine in July of 1993, Cobain addresses the royalty-percentage changes, by saying, "I write 99 percent of the songs," ... "I just felt entitled to it," ... "[I]t's only in one area of payment, just the songwriting credits." And, more interestingly, "Many were the times I've taken Krist's bass away from him and shown him what to play, and sat behind Dave's drum kit and shown him what to play."

This whole scenario with Kurt Cobain and Nirvana's Nevermind raises both philosophical and ethical questions.


First off, let's consider how this music was written. Particularly, how much of the music was written by Kurt Cobain before it was brought to Krist and Dave for the full blown "Nirvana" treatment?

The line of delineation must be drawn across authorship in the following way:
  • 1. If Kurt records a demo of guitar, bass, drums and vocals all by himself and brings it to Krist and Dave, then Krist and Dave are essentially "for hire" at this point. This is sometimes referred to as, "hired guns."  Kurt would be entitled to 100% ownership over the rights.
But, if...
  • 2. Kurt only brings a guitar part, and Krist and Dave add in bass and drums, this would represent a creative collaboration, and each member would be entitled to 33.3% of the rights/ownership.
Of course, the question is of origination. Some would say that because Kurt brought the guitar part to the writing session and started playing first, he might be entitled to full ownership over the resulting product, but certainly that's not true if Krist and Dave are contributing original music in an additive way. The decision point of what drum parts (Dave) and what bass parts (Krist) choose to play along with Kurt's guitar is a rights-to-ownership instance.

This all becomes mucky when it's a "behind-closed-doors" rehearsal of new material. And this is where ethics come into play. Because without any record of the rehearsal/writing session, it's easy for one of the contributors to claim ownership over more than their share of contribution. And it's hard to prove otherwise without any explicit proof.


"Smells like Teen Spirit" seems to be a unique case. Again, the "Transfer of copyright" looks like this:

"Smells like teen spirit / By Virgin Songs, Inc., as employer for hire of Kurt Cobain, Krist Novoselic & David Grohl. PA 541-273."

Why are Krist and Dave listed on this specific entry in the "Transfer of Copyright" filing? It seems as though they are listed because they are writers on the song, "Smells like teen spirit."

So, even if Kurt brought the lyrics and the guitar part to the writing session for "Teen spirit," it seems as though Krist and Dave contributed to the final iteration in such a way that they each retained a share of the rights over the track (perhaps not a full 33.3% share, but some sort of non-trivial percentage). 

Or, perhaps Kurt's "End of Music" company was forced to pay a certain royalty for "Teen spirit" over to Krist and Dave due to some other reason, as it pertains to Nirvana's initial contract with "Virgin Songs, Inc."

The fact "Smells like teen spirit" was a lead single off Nevermind could have granted Krist and Dave contractual ownership over the music as part of Nirvana's record deal. It's tough to say.


At the end of the day, these questions of music ethics are important. What happens behind the closed doors of a band in terms of writing and rehearsals is known only to those who were present. Of course, where there are demos, there is proof (more or less). At the end of the day, this sort of mental exercise is worthwhile. And, ultimately, the truth will set you free.

Perhaps Dave Grohl's creation of the "Foo Fighters" was a result of fatigue from the legal plyometrics of Nirvana. With Foo Fighters, Grohl was in the driver's seat. It was his time to maintain ownership over his own music, and create his own music ethics legacy. After all, he was the fifth drummer of Nirvana and despite the fact he brought them to a new level of success, he could be described as a "hired gun." And I'm sure that's extra tough considering the "Transfer of Copyright" filing where his creative contributions in terms of performance were legally invalidated for several of the tracks off Nevermind. Would the songs sound the same with a different drummer? Maybe close, but not exactly the same, no.

With Krist Novoselic it's more of an ethical question. He was a full-blown member of Nirvana from the early days. He was at every rehearsal, every show, until the end. So, does Kurt Cobain owe Krist a share of the royalties? Legally, it seems the answer is no, certainly not for music Krist didn't write. But ethically, this is where you could criticize Kurt's Cobain's decision to restructure the royalty agreement, maybe not from the perspective of a purist, but rather, a humanitarian.

Regardless, with full ownership over the copyrights to those 13 or 14 tracks, Cobain and his "End of Music" company could have still eventually decided to pay out Krist and Dave their original 33.3% royalties-owed, but we never made it that far. Until next time - Mike.

Friday, March 27, 2020

How I recorded a full album's worth of drums in two days

Recently I recorded a full album of drums. I guess these days the "album" is somewhat of a lost art.

Personally, I've always found a full album somewhat elusive. As a music writer I'm well-aware of what tends to occur during music-writing progress, particularly what happens when you aim high, and for a "full album."

An example of the charts I write out and then reference when recording drums for a song

Usually, when you continually fixate on creating a body of work such as an album, you start to lose focus on what's in front of you. My point is, you can only write one song at a time. Anyone's mind can work quite fast, and ideas may emerge at a rapid pace. You've got to adhere to a specific rule: one at a time. Everyone puts their pants on one leg at a time.

How I deal with any influx of creativity is often a "make or break" moment of music creation. This extends from a mental exercise to actual on-the-spot decision making, and years of habit-forming practice. I've found with music and with painting, you have to be ready in the moment with what decisions to make, because these decisions can impact the life-span of the work. For instance, tuning your drums, or replacing your guitar strings, or being careful when touching the dials on a mixing board, and the settings on a recording device (or not touching them) will impact the results of any recording. In the same way, making sure you have enough paint to finish that painting is just as important as those artful flicks of the wrist that cascade a waterfall of enamel across your masterpiece.

With a multitude of great ideas at your disposal, you may be tempted to spread them thinly over a set of songs, rather than select only the best parts for a singular creation. With this album of drums I went for a different approach.

Once again, I'm left with the clumsiness of a music-theory based description, but I'd like to bypass this (in my opinion) egoistic formalism. Instead, how about a simpler take. The man, in the woods, who hits a stick on a downed tree stump. With a little bit of rhythm (and some imagination) we're basically listening to ACDC's "Back in Black," if we want to be, or perhaps a whimsical Hendrix tune. All it takes is the tree branch.

To record the full album of drums what I did was to create charts based off of songs I like myself. I broke down each song by counting 8-beat measures. I literally counted out loud "1,2,3,4,5,6,7,8." Once I hit 8, I would write a number down and circle it. With each new circled number I was marking down song parts, i.e. Verse, chorus, bridge, and so on.

From there I was able to figure out how the songs were structured, and it didn't feel like a chore because I was listening to stuff I actually like a lot. Typically, a 4/4 song would have four consecutive 8-beat measures to round out half of a verse or chorus. 

I went one-at-a-time. I created a chart, then brought it over to the drum set. From there, I studied the piece of paper (on the floor by my hi-hat pedal) while I performed a totally indiscernable-from-the-source-material type of different drum pattern all-together (other than the format guidelines I provided for myself), and voila! I was left with a full set of drum tracks for an album. Wasn't so tough really.

From there, I brought my guitar over and basically just went off-the-cuff. At the end of the day I tracked bass (and scratch guitar) for all 10 songs. After a day, I decided two of my cuts were weak, and shortened the length to 8. Another day passed and I was content with 4 out of the 8. And yet another day, and I was down two 3 out of the original 10. At this point in time I'm now at two tracks that I will likely attempt vocals on. When it came to the guitar, the best results were just totally free-styled (after I made sure I was in-tune). The best part is when you start to realize in the moment you're crushing the take (out of nowhere, because, you're hearing the music for the first time yourself). It's at this moment you have to make sure to exercise a bit of caution, but also flash a bit of a switch-blade of risk as well. If you make it to the end of the tape even after this, you're onto something. - Mike

How I wrote/recorded my album "Disposable" (2025)

Click to listen on YouTube, out now!! This blog post will attempt to fully encapsulate as much of the writing/recording/mixing process of th...